Reasonable Doubt
State v. Eli MarshA pastor is murdered, a troubled young farmhand wakes up beside the body, and Clara takes the case nobody in Stillwater wants her to win.
In Stillwater, nothing stays buried.
A beloved pastor is stabbed to death in his own church. The town has its killer by morning. Defense attorney Clara Riggs is the only one asking why the case came together so fast.
She swore she'd never go back to court.
Once a rising prosecutor, Clara Riggs hasn't set foot in a courtroom in years, not since the justice system she gave her life to chewed her up and spat her out. These days she works the quiet end of criminal defense from a converted laundromat called The Soapbox, with her sharp-tongued, idealistic daughter Hazel as her reluctant intern.
Then Stillwater's beloved pastor is found dead in his church, and the town names its killer before the blood is dry. Eli Marsh is twenty-five, a farmhand with a record, a drinking problem and no memory of the night. His fingerprints are on the knife. The pastor's blood is on his shirt. Everyone in town is ready to convict him, and that is exactly what bothers Clara.
Hazel grew up with Eli, and she begs her mother to take the case. To save him, Clara will have to walk back into the one room she swore she'd never enter again and ask the questions Stillwater's most trusted people would rather leave alone.
It could redeem them both. Or it could destroy what's left of their family.
Each book is a standalone trial with its own verdict. Read them in order to follow what Clara uncovers about Stillwater, and about the people she trusted.
A pastor is murdered, a troubled young farmhand wakes up beside the body, and Clara takes the case nobody in Stillwater wants her to win.
Seven years after Joe Barber vanished, his bones turn up at a construction site. The town calls his widow the Black Widow, and she happens to be Clara's cousin.
A sixteen-year-old girl is killed on a dark road just outside town. The footage points to a young nursing student. Clara suspects someone far better loved in Stillwater.
Forty-three, a police officer's widow, and still haunted by the innocent man she helped convict. She runs her practice out of an old laundromat with a miniature labradoodle under the desk.
Clara's daughter. Idealistic and quick with a comeback, she is still grieving her father and tired of living in her mother's shadow.
A retired cop who knows which doors to knock on and which ones to watch. He finds what Clara needs, and sometimes what she'd rather not know.
Keeps The Soapbox running while her own bitter divorce threatens to boil over. Loyal, frank, and never short of an opinion.
Stillwater, Vermont
A postcard town of church steeples and sugar maples, where everyone knows your business and nobody forgets what you did. A tech company wants to build a data center on the edge of town, and the money is changing more than the skyline.
Join Eden's newsletter for news straight from Stillwater. No spam, and you can unsubscribe in one click.